home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=90TT3428>
- <link 91TT0541>
- <link 91TT0538>
- <link 91TT0271>
- <title>
- Dec. 24, 1990: Toward A New Kuwait
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1990
- Dec. 24, 1990 What Is Kuwait?
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- WORLD, Page 26
- COVER STORIES
- Toward A New Kuwait
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>By MICHAEL KRAMER/TAIF
- </p>
- <p> Most people know only one thing about Kuwait: that George
- Bush has pledged to free it. Nevertheless, a pernicious notion
- has taken hold. Kuwait, it is alleged, was an arrogant,
- undemocratic handkerchief of a country no one would care about
- were it not for the oil beneath its sands. Is that view
- accurate? And if so, could the nation change after its
- liberation? Kuwaitis themselves have a vested interest in the
- answers to those questions--but so does the rest of the
- world, and particularly the half-million allied troops massed
- for war in the gulf. For now that Saddam Hussein has released
- his foreign hostages, the question has become simpler: Is
- Kuwait worth dying for?
- </p>
- <p> When he thinks about it at all, which he tries hard not to
- do, Ali Basa can remember in detail exactly when his luck ran
- out. It was shortly after 1 p.m. on Tuesday, Aug. 28, at a
- point in the Kuwaiti desert about 14 miles north of the Saudi
- border. On eight previous smuggling runs, the midday heat had
- protected Basa's overland enterprise. The Iraqis, everyone
- knew, were creatures of habit who invariably shunned the harsh
- sun.
- </p>
- <p> But not on this day.
- </p>
- <p> The cloud of dust that moved furiously toward Basa's
- three-vehicle convoy telegraphed the worst news possible. An
- Iraqi patrol--two armed jeeps--was converging on Basa's
- position. As planned in advance, Basa quickly shifted his
- Nissan out of four-wheel drive. In a moment, he was stuck in
- the loose sand. In another, he was in custody. But Basa's
- confederates got away, their Chevy Blazers roaring off for
- Kuwait City. By nightfall they would resupply the Kuwaiti
- resistance with 90 AK-47 assault rifles, 17 rocket-propelled
- grenade launchers, 5,000 rounds of ammunition and, at $25,000
- each, three more mobile telephones equipped with portable
- satellite dishes--high-tech communications systems capable
- of connecting those "inside" with the outside world.
- </p>
- <p> To close friends familiar with Basa's activities, his daring
- had earned him a nickname. He was the "Hero of the Crossing,"
- the same admiring sobriquet awarded Anwar Sadat after the
- Egyptian army crossed the Suez Canal during the 1973 October
- War with Israel. Now, at 40, with a wife and nine children
- safely out of Kuwait, Basa was headed for jail with phony
- papers identifying him as a citizen of Qatar. "That's what
- saved me," says Basa, recalling the story he had carefully
- rehearsed against the possibility of capture. "I told the Iraqis
- that I was just another expatriate who had worked in Kuwait.
- I told them that my mother-in-law was a Kuwaiti, that she was
- ill, and that I wanted to bring her out for medical treatment
- at `home' in Qatar. There was nothing to say otherwise. I had
- nothing on me, and the truck was empty. I was the decoy, and
- no one could prove it."
- </p>
- <p> But many tried. It would be 10 days, three beatings and more
- than a dozen interrogations before Basa's elaborate lie finally
- stuck; 10 days of hell before he was released by being tossed
- from a moving car near one of the new statues of Saddam Hussein
- in the middle of Kuwait City.
- </p>
- <p> During his detention at an Iraqi checkpoint, Basa shared a
- cell with three other Kuwaitis. Two of the three were tortured
- while Basa was forced to watch. "They wanted names, resistance
- leaders, people they could go after," he says. "One fellow had
- his genitals prodded with an electric rod. After that he was
- made to sit on a broken Pepsi bottle. Then, working very
- slowly, they ripped the fingernails off his right hand. He
- broke, of course. Who wouldn't? He gave them some names. And
- then they killed him. A single shot between the eyes."
- </p>
- <p> Of greater importance than anything Basa and a score of
- others smuggled into Kuwait was the wealth of data they
- smuggled out. Within a day of the Iraqi invasion on Aug. 2, the
- Kuwaiti government, already operating in Saudi Arabia, had
- compiled an intriguing shopping list--computerized
- information desperately needed for the country's business to
- continue despite the nation's physical occupation. "We are not
- called Kuwait Inc. for nothing," says Basa, who ran a small
- construction company before August and is now living with his
- family in Cairo. "Before we are a nation, we are a business.
- The nationality records we recovered can tell us who was a real
- resident of Kuwait and who was not, and that is obviously
- important. But the real lode was the nation's financial and
- banking records." All told, about 85% of that material was
- smuggled out, and the rest was reconstructed by late October.
- So Kuwait, or at least Kuwait Inc., is offshore now--an
- economy in exile.
- </p>
- <p> To many, Kuwait Inc. is a term of derision. To Kuwaitis, the
- staggering fortune their nation has accumulated, and
- particularly the way it has been invested and saved, is a
- matter of pride. With 94.5 billion bbl. of oil in the ground,
- enough for more than a century of production, Kuwait boasts the
- world's third largest proven petroleum reserves. But unlike
- other nations, which spend their oil revenues almost as fast
- as they come in, Kuwait long ago decided to save for the future.
- So successful has the effort been that for some years before
- Saddam's perfidy, Kuwait was reaping more yearly income from
- its overseas investments than from the sale and marketing of
- its crude oil and refined products.
- </p>
- <p> Kuwait's foreign-asset portfolio approaches a monumental
- $100 billion, which is invested in a bewildering array of
- stocks, bonds and entire companies around the world. Almost 70%
- of the total has been segregated for use when the wells run
- dry. The Fund for Future Generations, as it is called, is a
- model of enlightened policy and smart politics. "Other rulers
- in other places have kept the money for themselves and their
- friends, doling out just enough to keep their populations
- contained during their reigns," says Jasem Mohammed al-Hussein,
- a wealthy Kuwaiti businessman. "Our rulers, the Sabahs, have
- earned our loyalty by providing for our grandchildren. That
- foresight, I am sure, is one of the reasons why Saddam has
- failed to find a Kuwaiti quisling to govern Kuwait in his
- name."
- </p>
- <p> While Kuwait's investments bring in about $20 million a day,
- the economy-in-exile is driven by another engine as well, the
- Kuwait Petroleum Corp., the world's 12th largest oil company.
- From its London office on New Bond Street, KPC and its
- subsidiaries own and operate a fleet of tankers, oil and gas
- exploration companies in 22 countries on five continents, and
- 6,500 Q8 gas stations situated throughout Europe.
- </p>
- <p> Millions have been allocated to support Kuwaitis stranded
- abroad. In Britain more than 6,000 Kuwaiti nationals enjoy
- monthly stipends for housing and food, supplements that average
- more than $3,000 for a family of four. Far larger sums have
- been pledged to the U.S. for Operation Desert Shield and to
- nations like Turkey and Egypt that are suffering collaterally
- from the economic embargo of Iraq: a total of $5 billion in the
- last five months of 1990 alone.
- </p>
- <p> Kuwait could be expected to support those who may yet fight
- for its liberation, as well as to help those innocently hurt
- by the sanctions designed to compel Saddam's surrender. What
- is truly impressive, however, is the continuation of Kuwait's
- generous foreign-assistance programs. Over two decades, that
- aid has exceeded $17 billion--an average 6% of GNP yearly,
- a percentage many times as great as that of any other nation
- over a comparable period.
- </p>
- <p> Kuwait's humanitarianism is both real and self-serving.
- Genuine sympathy for the less fortunate reflects fresh memory:
- Kuwait was among the poorest of nations before the oil started
- flowing in 1946. But because envy is second only to petroleum
- as the Middle East's leading product, common sense dictates
- that a small and relatively defenseless nation seek goodwill
- however it can. "Better to share some of the wealth than have
- those who are strong but poor want to come and take it," says
- a Kuwaiti foreign-aid official. Recalling that Iraq was a
- longtime beneficiary of his nation's financial assistance, a
- Kuwaiti diplomat admits that "our `buy them off' strategy can
- be seen to have failed." On the other hand, he adds, "we
- interpret the willingness of so many Arab states to join the
- coalition against Saddam as a kind of payback to us for so many
- years of our helping them. In any event, we are committed to
- continue as we have. It is both right and necessary that we do
- so. We will always be weak militarily, and Saddam isn't the
- only despot around."
- </p>
- <p> While the policy of Kuwait's exiled economy is executed in
- London, it is determined in Taif, a Saudi town set atop a
- mountain about 40 miles southeast of Mecca. The Saudis chose
- Taif for the Kuwaitis because it is relatively inaccessible.
- The main road leading to the mountaintop culminates in a
- switchback that a platoon could defend against a division of
- aggressors. Together with his ministers and top staff, Kuwait's
- Emir, Sheik Jaber al-Ahmad al-Sabah, 64, lives and works out
- of the Sheraton Hotel near Taif. Modern and antiseptic, the
- hotel is instantly familiar to frequent travelers. Three
- corridors project as spokes from a central atrium that rises
- seven stories. The top-floor restaurant is open to all
- regardless of rank, but the ministers eat together at three
- tables set to the side, well out of earshot of the aides who
- serve them.
- </p>
- <p> Ministries that once occupied whole buildings in Kuwait
- function out of single rooms. One can find the Finance
- Ministry, for example, in Room 311. Surrounded by six chairs,
- two card tables in the middle of the room offer all the flat
- work space available. Several phones and a single fax machine
- connect the ministry with the rest of the world. There are two
- currency counters and enough calculators to ensure that Kuwait
- Inc. functions to the proper decimal points. A shredder sits
- near a large safe, opposite a small television set. But CNN,
- which everyone is eager to watch, is available only on another
- TV, two floors up--a Saudi concession, since the kingdom
- prohibits the public reception of CNN everywhere else.
- </p>
- <p> Without a country to govern, many in Taif have little to do
- but worry. They dial around the world in search of news, play
- countless rounds of hand, the 14-card Kuwaiti version of gin
- rummy, and recall receiving Iraqi television transmissions at
- home in Kuwait. "Saddam was on all the time," says a Kuwaiti
- minister. "On any given day you could see him instructing women
- on how to make tomato paste, or children on how to brush their
- teeth. It was some of the best comedy around."
- </p>
- <p> Not everyone in Taif is idle, of course. With critical
- chores to perform, the Finance Ministry, for one, churns almost
- around the clock. The Finance Minister, Sheik Ali al-Khalifa
- al-Sabah, 45, known to all as Abu Khalifa--and to a few close
- friends as Ali Cash--is highly regarded among both Kuwaitis
- and foreigners. "He can sell you the shirt off your back while
- you're wearing it," says a friend, affectionately. "He is
- absolutely one of the smartest, shrewdest people I have ever
- met."
- </p>
- <p> Although born into the ruling Sabah family, which now
- numbers about 1,000 extended relatives, Khalifa worked his way
- up through various jobs in the Finance and Oil ministries. Over
- the past 12 years he has held each of those crucial Cabinet
- portfolios several times, and was once minister of both
- simultaneously.
- </p>
- <p> Until he was 12, Khalifa attended elementary school in
- Baghdad, where his Iraqi-born mother went to live after her
- husband died. Khalifa learned English at a private academy in
- Cairo, and like every Kuwaiti who wanted a college education
- before Kuwait University was inaugurated in 1966, went abroad
- to study. Before being graduated with a B.A. in mathematics
- from San Francisco State University, Khalifa spent two years
- at Berkeley, where his chemistry lab partner was Mario Savio,
- the radical student leader who founded the Free Speech Movement.
- </p>
- <p>"We studied a bit, attended anti-Vietnam demonstrations and
- listened to Joan Baez, who was always around singing."
- </p>
- <p> Pegged a comer early on, Khalifa worked for the Finance
- Ministry between graduate studies in London and Beirut, often
- jetting home weekly for meetings. Before he was 30, Khalifa was
- representing Kuwait at important OPEC meetings. "I remember
- once when I went to Baghdad to explain our views on oil
- prices," says Khalifa. "After I finished my presentation, I was
- called to another building to see Saddam. Before I could go
- through it all again, Saddam said, `Khalifa, your explanation
- is not valid.' There had been no time for anyone at the earlier
- meeting to have briefed him, but Saddam knew exactly what I had
- said. Even then he had everything bugged."
- </p>
- <p> It was Khalifa who designed many of Kuwait's successful
- investment strategies, and Khalifa who reorganized Kuwait's oil
- industry following the government's 1975 takeover of the Kuwait
- Oil Co.--a joint venture of Gulf Oil Corp. and British
- Petroleum. And now, to no one's surprise, it is Khalifa who is
- at the center of his country's most ambitious effort: the
- attempt to reinvent Kuwait. If implemented in its entirety, the
- intricate and politically tricky plan could transform the
- demography, character and economy of what everyone involved is
- calling New Kuwait.
- </p>
- <p> A mere generation ago, the people of the Arabian shore of
- the Persian Gulf led a life little different from the one their
- ancestors had led since the advent of Islam. During migrations
- in search of water and trading locations, mainly from the Najd
- region of what is today the central part of Saudi Arabia, a
- group of tribes called the Bani Utub settled the town of Kuwait
- (in simple translation, Little Fort) in the early 1700s. With
- trade the major source of income, the tribes established a
- unique political system. Of the three most influential
- families, the Khalifas and the Jalahimas concerned themselves
- with commerce; the third, the Sabahs, governed. Having
- voluntarily created an oligarchy of competing interests,
- Kuwait, in effect, was ruled by popular consent. The contract
- among the families was the seed of a quasi-democratic tradition
- that has persisted for nearly three centuries.
- </p>
- <p> When the oil money started accumulating seriously in the
- early 1950s, the Sabahs concocted a sophisticated scheme for
- distributing the windfall. Kuwait City, where 80% of the
- population still lives (or lived before August), was a town of
- mud huts. The Emir set about building a modern metropolis, a
- place not unlike Houston, with its skyscraper business center
- surrounded by villa-style suburbs. In Kuwait, too, each
- "suburb" became a self-contained microcosm of a city. The
- neighborhoods were established as cooperatives. Each had its
- own supermarkets, schools, medical centers and municipal
- services.
- </p>
- <p> While merely convenient before Aug. 2, the system has served
- as a lifeline since the invasion. By all accounts, Kuwait City
- is functioning well for Kuwaitis; however onerous the
- occupation, Iraq's control of the city is not total.
- Neighborhood committees provide a range of services one would
- think impossible in the circumstances: food that was secreted
- in the early days of August is distributed according to need,
- rudimentary medical service is available, and as the world now
- knows, scores of foreigners were successfully hidden from Iraqi
- authorities for more than four months.
- </p>
- <p> Some of those foreigners actively helped the resistance. "We
- taught them how to make homemade Claymore mines and various
- antipersonnel devices," says Joseph Lammerding, an American
- engineer who worked for the Kuwaiti military. "You would take
- quarter sticks of TNT, which are commonly used in oil drilling,
- dip them in glue and roll them in buckshot," he explains. "Then
- you would set them off in the middle of a group of Iraqis. To
- make homemade plastic explosives, you would cook a mixture of
- diesel oil and powdered soap."
- </p>
- <p> Realizing the Sabahs' vision of a modern city-state required
- land expropriation--an action that normally leaves
- individuals poorer but that the Sabahs contrived as a wealth
- spreader. After a straight-up appraisal of land and homes,
- people were compensated at rates that often surpassed five
- times market value. The newly "homeless" pocketed most of the
- money, since they were given low-interest loans to build new
- houses and were granted land that had previously been used by
- grazing sheep and goats.
- </p>
- <p> The Sabahs also instituted a cradle-to-grave welfare system.
- Education, health care and every public utility were provided
- free, or nearly so. And every Kuwaiti--even the illiterate--was guaranteed a government job for life, as intriguing a
- way of distributing the booty as was ever invented.
- </p>
- <p> To serve the prosperous and perform most of the work, large
- numbers of foreign workers were attracted to Kuwait by wages
- far higher than those they could command at home. In the role
- of contractors, importers, landlords and bankers, many Kuwaitis
- found themselves members of a privileged minority set above the
- expatriate work force. A law enacted in the late 1950s required
- foreign businessmen to take Kuwaiti partners, another risk-free
- method of wealth creation that made millionaires of many
- overnight.
- </p>
- <p> "It is wonderful on paper," says Hasan al-Ebraheem, a former
- Kuwaiti Education Minister. "But it has had awful
- repercussions." By the time of Saddam's invasion, the cleavage
- between Kuwaitis and non-Kuwaitis had worsened considerably.
- Foreigners account for more than 60% of Kuwait's population and
- more than 80% of its work force. "Oil exacerbated the
- underlying tensions," says Saad Eddin Ibrahim, an Egyptian
- political sociology professor at the American University in
- Cairo. "The fantastic wealth made all Kuwaitis keener on
- emphasizing their Kuwaitiness because being Kuwaiti meant
- enormous privileges."
- </p>
- <p> It is not that the Kuwaitis were ungenerous. The
- welfare-state umbrella covered non-Kuwaitis almost as well as
- it protected the natives. Expatriates could prosper, and many
- did. But everything about the rest of a foreigner's life in
- Kuwait was demonstrably second class. As naturalization was
- almost impossible, an expatriate's stay in the country depended
- on the whim of his employer. Noncitizens could be deported
- without recourse, and they frequently were when economic demand
- slackened or political crisis threatened. Foreigners could not
- own homes or land. Those who worked for the government were
- eligible for subsidized housing. Those employed in the private
- sector were forced to find lodgings on the open market, which
- often meant living in slums, since rents were exorbitant. In
- time, a housing apartheid grew, with some of the Palestinian
- neighborhoods dubbed "Gaza" and "the West Bank." Even the
- Kuwaiti-born children of foreigners could be expelled from the
- only country they had ever known if they were unable to find
- work on their own account when they reached 18.
- </p>
- <p> There was something of a two-tier system among Kuwaitis
- themselves. Like preferred shareholders in a corporation that
- issues A and B stock, only males whose forebears were residents
- before 1920 were entitled to vote--a mere 85,000 out of
- 826,500 Kuwaitis.
- </p>
- <p> Restricted enfranchisement is only one of the complaints
- voiced by those who perceive Kuwait as undemocratic: women
- could not vote; permits required for public rallies were rarely
- granted; demonstrators were dispersed by force; political
- parties were banned. When the parliament was suspended in 1986,
- the press was censored as well, a particularly depressing
- action because Kuwait's papers, books and magazines had long
- been among the freest in the region. Whether it was accurate
- news from Lebanon or the Arabic version of Sesame Street, it
- could well have originated in Kuwait.
- </p>
- <p> Still, an interesting anomaly existed. Even before the
- invasion--which has naturally caused Kuwaitis to unite behind
- their leaders--most of those depressed by Kuwait's democratic
- failings supported the Emir and Kuwait's system of government.
- Part of the reason is simple. To a Western eye, the list of
- authoritarian transgressions is chilling, but to those who live
- in the Middle East, Kuwait was something of a model of
- political openness. "The fact is that we could criticize
- everything, even the Emir, without fear of reprisal," says
- Abdulatif al-Tourah, a KPC employee. "If you spoke out as freely
- in other Arab societies as we did all the time in Kuwait, you
- could be jailed or killed."
- </p>
- <p> If New Kuwait ever comes to exist, the complaints about a
- lack of democracy may be moot. The Emir has promised to restore
- the parliament and increase political freedoms in general. No
- one claims to have spoken to a Kuwaiti who doubts that pledge.
- "After liberation," says Professor Ibrahim, the Egyptian
- sociologist, "I foresee Kuwait as an ever more democratic state--and for that alone it is worth fighting for. But more, you
- would be fighting for all the principles that the people in the
- Arab world aspire to."
- </p>
- <p> Unique among refugee communities, Kuwait itself has the
- wherewithal to rebuild its nation. The estimated $20 billion
- in physical damage is severe but not an impediment--and
- planning and purchasing for the future are already well under
- way. Assisted by about 50 U.S. Army civil-affairs reservists,
- the cream of Kuwait's ministerial employees have been meeting
- quietly in a downtown Washington office building for six weeks.
- While Finance Minister Khalifa conceived the project and
- continues to monitor its progress, the day-to-day work is being
- directed by Fawzi al-Sultan, a Yale-educated Kuwaiti who has
- been a World Bank executive director since 1984. Every
- conceivable need is being addressed. Enough material to equip
- eight hospitals and a score of clinics, for example, is being
- purchased from U.S. and European medical-supply companies.
- </p>
- <p> More difficult than the task of physically rebuilding Kuwait
- are the problems of equity that will arise when Kuwaitis
- return. "For example," wonders Khalifa, "what is fair
- compensation for loss? Assume that one person's house was worth
- $1 million before it was destroyed by the Iraqis and that
- another's was worth $100,000. Does the government assist both
- to the same degree in dollar amount or in percentage or what?
- What's fair? What will wash?"
- </p>
- <p> But even questions of fairness are dwarfed by the angst that
- will attend the truly invasive societal changes contemplated
- for New Kuwait. If there is a consensus among Kuwaitis about
- anything, it is this: despite its vast wealth, Kuwait's society
- was sick, and not merely because of democratic failings or the
- poor treatment of expatriates. "At bottom," says Hasan
- al-Ebraheem, the former Education Minister, "much was rotted."
- </p>
- <p> Harsh as it may seem, al-Ebraheem's assessment is common.
- Across the ideological spectrum--from those who regularly
- opposed the ruling elite's every move to some of the elite's
- most prominent members--the echo startles. "Ours was a
- culture of dependency," says Tareq al-Suwaidan, a leader of the
- opposition Islamic Trend movement. "We were the pampered
- product of an affluent society taken to the nth degree," says
- Minister of Planning Sulaiman Mutawa. "Everywhere," remarks Ali
- Jaber al-Sabah, a KPC managing director, "there was the spirit
- of ba'dain, of `tomorrow.' Any real change was put off. `Why
- bother?' people would say. `We're making money, the country as
- a company is making a good return. We'll decide the hard things
- tomorrow.' But of course tomorrow never came."
- </p>
- <p> "Most Kuwaitis were spoiled beyond imagination," says Saud
- Nasser al-Sabah, Kuwait's ambassador to the U.S. Except at KPC
- and the investment office, lean and mean because they were (and
- still are) the lifeblood of the country, merit counted for
- nothing. "There was no accountability," says Khalifa, "because
- government employees were promoted automatically. It was
- impossible to fire civil servants. Several years ago the
- parliament passed an amazing law. In effect, it said that if
- someone was performing poorly, he would have been fired. But,
- says this law, since he was not fired, then by definition he
- was performing well, and that, in turn, means that he is
- entitled to a pay raise, if not a promotion, on a regular
- basis."
- </p>
- <p> A long-overdue merit system will probably take shape in New
- Kuwait. But many of those who supported such a move when it was
- only a theory may recoil when faced with it in reality. Many
- will also be upset by a shrinkage in the welfare state's
- blanket coverage. Modest steps were already in place before
- August. Budgetary constraints alone will justify further
- cutbacks--and many would-be recipients will be furious.
- </p>
- <p> Education in Kuwait will change too. "Today," says Ali
- Jaber, whose view is typical, "people go for the sheepskin, not
- for the knowledge. With employment assured, there is no need
- to actually learn anything if you are not self-motivated."
- Performance and accountability "are only the beginning of the
- new discipline we are going to have to inject into our school
- system," says Hasan al-Ebraheem. "We have to break up the
- university, create elite centers of training in specific skills
- like banking and business, and then we have to encourage those
- who cannot make it in those places to accept vocational
- training."
- </p>
- <p> The proposed shift in education policy will aid a radical
- transformation of Kuwait's economy. As oil is a nonrenewable
- resource, Kuwait's leaders are eager for their country to
- develop in new directions. "We can become the Route 128 of the
- Middle East," says Fawzi al-Sultan, referring to Boston's
- beltway dotted with high-tech managerial and consulting firms.
- "We can be the financial brains behind industrial enterprises
- in the rest of the gulf and in the Arab world at large. As our
- ancestors were often away as merchant traders, so large numbers
- of us can be working abroad in Kuwaiti-owned enterprises and
- for others. But only if we are properly trained."
- </p>
- <p> Self-reliance, efficiency, a genuine work ethic: ambitious
- goals that defy dissent. But how can they triumph over ba'dain?
- </p>
- <p> The centerpiece of New Kuwait, the key to everything its
- leaders envision, will be an unprecedented demographic
- make-over. As quickly as possible, Kuwait's population will be
- dramatically reduced, perhaps even halved. "How do you get
- people to actually stop being lazy?" asks Ambassador Saud. "Why
- should anyone care about a real education, or making do with
- fewer handouts?" asks Hasan al-Ebraheem. The answer is that
- nothing will change unless everything changes. And the way for
- everything to change is to take a country that had more than 2
- million people before August and recreate it with only 1
- million. "The only way to exit the trap of dependency," says
- Tareq al-Suwaidan, the opposition leader, who wholeheartedly
- shares the planners' dreams of a new Kuwaiti demography, "is
- to make it impossible for people to be reliant on others. Most
- of those who have done the real work in the past will have to
- go. Then there will be no choice. The rest of us will have to
- do the hard work."
- </p>
- <p> There are two ways to accomplish a cultural transformation
- of the magnitude contemplated. One is by governmental decree.
- The other is to let market forces play. While the goal is set--if still unstated--the manner of execution is not. Those
- planning for New Kuwait hope for fiat but are prepared for the
- slower course. "If, for example, the welfare system is cut
- back," says Fawzi al-Sultan, "if a person who has three
- servants, which is not unusual, suddenly has to pay the medical
- bills of those servants in place of the government, then that
- person is going to think twice about having three as help. So
- market forces can do the job. It takes more time, but it may
- be less risky politically."
- </p>
- <p> Who exactly would be forced to leave New Kuwait, and who
- could stay or come? If foreign professionals are still needed,
- the preferred will be nationals of the countries that supported
- Kuwait against Iraq. Which means that the Palestinians once
- more in their history will lose out. "We were welcome at the
- beginning," says Khalid, a Palestinian who worked for the
- Kuwait municipality until 1988. "We worked hard to build their
- country"--as Kuwait worked hard to support the Palestinian
- cause abroad.
- </p>
- <p> Many of the original founders of the P.L.O. began their
- careers and formed their revolutionary strategy in Kuwait in
- the late 1950s, including Yasser Arafat, who was a civil
- engineer in Kuwait's public-works ministry while organizing
- Fatah on the side. It was Kuwait that arranged the infamous
- meeting between the P.L.O.'s United Nations representative and
- U.S. Ambassador Andrew Young; Kuwait that refused the nomination
- of an American ambassador because he had previously served as
- consul in Jerusalem; Kuwait that broke diplomatic relations
- with West Germany in 1965, when Bonn recognized Israel; Kuwait
- that dutifully deducted a tithe from the salaries of
- Palestinians working for the Kuwaiti government for remittance
- to the P.L.O.; and Kuwait that coughed up millions whenever
- Yasser Arafat cried bankruptcy--at least $60 million over the
- past six years alone.
- </p>
- <p> "With a record like that," says Ahmad, a Palestinian
- schoolteacher, "who would not feel betrayed by the P.L.O.'s
- support of Iraq? I would not deny that some Palestinians have
- looted and done despicable things in Kuwait, but most of us are
- against what Saddam did. That won't matter, of course. We will
- be punished for the stupidity of our chief of state--and
- Arafat will continue his life as a celebrity. The Kuwaitis will
- say that they will look at each of our cases one by one"--which indeed is what the Kuwaiti leadership says--"but in the
- end I am sure that almost all of us will be kicked out."
- </p>
- <p> Booting the Palestinians will be painful, which is where
- foreign policy comes in. Many Kuwaitis expect--and would
- welcome--an indefinite U.S. troop presence on their soil.
- "Reflagging" the effort by adding Arab troops could make the
- action more palatable, but "it is the Americans we need," says
- a Kuwaiti official, "more for pretext than for security. Do you
- think the U.S. will want a potential Palestinian terrorist
- threat close to its troops? We don't." There were more than
- 300,000 Palestinians in Kuwait before Aug. 2. "If there are
- 100,000 left a year from the end of this, I will be surprised,"
- says a senior official at Kuwait's Higher Planning Council.
- </p>
- <p> Will the radical measures planned in exile be accepted at
- home? Rather than propel change, the shock of invasion may
- hinder it. "To cope with what has happened," says Hasan
- al-Ebraheem, "many have come to think of this time as a
- temporary setback, like an earthquake. Psychologically, people
- will want to recreate the past as exactly as they can in order
- to forget what has happened. That is what we must resist. This
- is a golden opportunity, the invasion's silver lining. If we
- give in to sentiment and let the old ways come back while
- saying that we'll reach the hard issues later, we will never
- reach them."
- </p>
- <p> To retard backsliding, Fawzi al-Sultan's planners in
- Washington are effectively rigging the assumptions. When the
- group's health expert, or the men from public works, for
- example, draft their recovery plans, the first question is
- always, How many people are we supposed to plan for? "When the
- working hypothesis is 1.3 million, tops," says al-Sultan, "the
- answers come out in a certain way. Lock those premises in, and
- the shape of the society will change. Demography is everything."
- </p>
- <p> Whether by war or by peaceful means, Iraq's occupation of
- Kuwait will eventually end. Kuwait Inc. will thrive as it
- always has, as will most Kuwaitis. The question then is whether
- Kuwait, the nation, can become New Kuwait.
- </p>
- <p> The criticisms of Kuwait have always been overdrawn. At most
- levels they are simplistic. Often they remind a Westerner of
- how difficult it was to talk to a communist about the U.S. when
- one tried to explain that America's society was basically good
- despite segregation. In their hearts and minds, Americans
- believed that completely--and eventually, of course, the
- remnants of at least legal discrimination were abolished.
- Similarly, Kuwait's problems should be seen in context. Like
- Israel, an essentially decent nation despite some glaring blind
- spots, Kuwait before Saddam was a good country in a bad
- neighborhood. It will surely be that again, but it could be
- much more. A terrible tragedy has afforded Kuwait the rarest
- of opportunities, a true second chance. If it rises to the
- challenge, a good country could become a great one.
- </p>
- <p>_
- KUWAIT'S HOLDINGS
- </p>
- <p> From a nondescript seven-story London building called St.
- Vedast House, the Kuwait investment Office manages close to
- $100 billion in foreign assets. "The Office," as it is known to
- financiers around the world, controls about half the total.
- A web of banks and other institutions invests the rest.
- Performance standards are rigorous. "The amounts involved
- generate considerable commissions," says Kuwaits finance
- minister, Ali Khalifa al-Sabah. "We rarely get anything but the
- best people working on our accounts." In addition to the
- representative list of holdings below, Kuwait Inc. holds
- sizable positions in all of the New York Stock Exchange's top
- 100 corporations--3 million shares of IBM common stock, for
- example.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-